Tied house laws and category management_ a continuing quandary – lexology

On March 16, the federal Alcohol and Tobacco Tax and Trade Bureau (TTB) published a list of frequently asked questions expanding further on a ruling issued in February on application of the federal “tied house law” to industry promotional activities, specifically category management practices employed by retailers.

TTB claims that a formal rulemaking to revise its tied house regulations is not necessary: “TTB Ruling 2016-1 merely provides guidance as to the plain meaning of the existing regulation under 27 CFR 6.99(b). Definition of a trader It does not change TTB’s longstanding position, nor does it change the meaning of the plain language of this regulatory exception.” So let’s look at the plain language:

The act by an industry member [supplier or wholesaler] of providing a recommended shelf plan or shelf schematic for distilled spirits, wine, or malt beverages does not constitute a means to induce within the meaning of section 105(b)(3) of the [Federal Alcohol Administration (FAA)] Act.

That statement on its face is an open-ended authorization to provide shelf schematics. Trade journals or publications definition It says nothing about the products of other industry members or whether the plan is written on a napkin or in a sophisticated IT system that is used for inventory management at hundreds of stores.


Reading the regulation in the context of related regulations is not helpful. Inter industry trade definition The prior section authorizes suppliers and wholesalers to assist retailers by affixing prices to products. Trade accounts receivable definition Some may recall President George H.W. Trade deal definition Bush being ridiculed because he expressed amazement at a supermarket scanner during the 1992 campaign. Definition of international trade by different authors TTB regulations were published in 1995, and the end of affixing prices to containers was clearly drawing near.

Other sections of federal tied house regulations and the new FAQs raise the threat to retailer independence as a policy issue. Informal trade barriers definition Many alcohol beverage laws are intended to protect retailer independence, but regulators will be hard-pressed to show that the category management poses a threat to the independence of modern retailers who use the same practices for thousands of other items and who have no problem asserting their prerogatives to suppliers and wholesalers.

During the last two decades, the retail tier has changed dramatically. Trade deficit definition Technology has advanced light years; yet, TTB’s 1995 regulations remain the same. Wholesale trade definition The law cited to authorize the regulations has not been revised since it was signed by President Franklin D. External trade definition Roosevelt in 1935.

TTB’s FAQs further acknowledge that “the terms ‘category management’ and ‘category captain’ are not defined in the TTB regulations and can mean different things to different industry members.” That statement could be reasonably interpreted to mean that category management is simply not addressed in federal law, which certainly makes sense given the age of the FAA Act.

Category management principles are employed by a wide range of consumer products retailers. Trade definition economics In 2015, the White House announced an initiative for the federal government to employ category management from the buyer’s perspective to make smarter purchases in “important spending areas like IT, transportation, travel, and professional services.”

Maximizing use of retail space provides more room for competing beer, wine and spirits offerings to consumers, which should reduce the potential for exclusion. Direct trade definition These practices have been openly discussed for years at dozens of industry meetings in the presence of TTB executives. What is trade agreement definition If TTB believes that category management is a pressing alcohol beverage control policy issue, industry members need basic definitions and fair notice of practices that lead to exclusion of competing products and a violation of the FAA Act.

TTB’s press release announcing the FAQs includes a commitment to the laudable goal of ensuring a level playing field through enforcement of the trade practices provisions of the Federal Alcohol Administration Act.” To the extent a federal agency can ensure an even playing field in any endeavor, a set of clear rules is required to provide the industry with fair notice and encourage voluntary compliance.

Absent new regulations or a clear authorization from Congress defining category management and potential problems, Ruling 2016-1 and the FAQs are likely to trigger dozens of new questions from industry members competing in a complex and diffuse area of interstate and international commerce. Definition for trademark Beyond attempting to define the “problem,” a rulemaking process would also help TTB determine whether category management actually threatens an even playing field in the alcohol beverage industry or undermines any other legitimate federal policy goal.

“Lexology is a quick and useful indicator of developments in the legal sphere. Definition international trade It alerts me to changes taking place in the legal environment in South Africa that I may not otherwise have spotted or had immediate access to as a company lawyer. Trade price definition It definitely serves as a trigger for me to investigate such changes in the legal landscape in South Africa as they may affect my work and that of my employer. Definition of trade show I believe that receiving Lexology provides me with a competitive advantage.”

All materials are found on open spaces of a network the Internet as freely extended and laid out exclusively in the fact-finding purposes. If you are what lawful legal owner or a product and against its placing on the given site, inform us and we will immediately remove the given material. The administration of a site does not bear responsibility for actions of the visitors breaking copyrights. abuzesite@bigmir.net